Published in the Huffington Post Thursday November 3, 2016
Free trade rarely comes cheap, and too often the price is just too high.
Unifor members from across Canada are bringing this message to Ottawa this week as they meet with Members of Parliament to talk about the Trans-Pacific Partnership.
Public consultations on the TPP – a 12-member trade deal of Pacific Rim nations including Canada, Australia, Brunei Darussalam, Chile, Japan, Malaysia, Mexico, New Zealand, Peru, Singapore, the U.S. and Vietnam – were due to end October 31, but have now been extended to the end of January.
After that, debate on the deal moves to Parliament Hill toward a possible ratification vote in the House of Commons in 2017. Unifor is in Ottawa this week in anticipation of that vote.
We are urging the government to live up to another promise and to strengthen electoral democracy by allowing a free vote on the TPP. All MPs should be able to vote their conscious on the TPP, rather than having their votes dictated to them by party leadership. During the last federal election, the Liberals promised more free votes in the House so MPs could more effectively represent their constituents.
The TPP is an issue that demands our representation. It will affect every Canadian, but will have specific and diverse impacts on different parts of the country.
Auto communities will be particularly hard hit by the TPP, but this trade deal will hurt those communities with strong dairy, forestry and aerospace industries and others, as well.
While the TPP’s impact on health care and the cost of prescription drugs should be a concern to all Canadians, MPs with large numbers of aging constituents might want to pay particular attention to this issue.
Those from ridings where the environment is a key issue, for instance, might want to consider the impact of the TPP’s Investor State Disputes Settlement (ISDS) system on Canada’s ability to pass new laws.
For those concerned about the impact of modern technology in our lives, the concerns raised by Open Media about our digital rights and threats to an open Internet under the TPP might be of interest.
With so many distinct and varied ways the TPP might affect constituents, the only way for MPs to properly represent their ridings is with a free vote.
Despite all the high costs that come with the TPP, the potential payoff is very low. Even the most optimistic projections show only anemic growth from this deal. If the TPP won’t boost trade in any meaningful way, there’s really no reason to risk its potential high costs.
In short, the payoff for ratifying the TPP is insignificant, and the price is too high. It’s just too dangerous.
We have heard similar concerns coming out of Europe over the past few weeks as the people of Wallonia, a region of Belgium, stood up against Canada’s trade deal with the European Union, the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA).
There, the parliament of Wallonia threatened to scuttle the entire CETA, in large part over objections to the deal’s investor-state dispute mechanism – which allows corporations to sue governments if laws hurt their profits, even if those laws are in the public interest.
While a compromise was reached allowing the prime minister to fly to Brussels over the weekend to sign the deal, CETA is still a long way from being ratified or implemented.
Under the Wallonia deal, CETA’s investor rights provisions must be sent to the European Court of Justice to test its legality. It is far from certain that these provisions can survive this test.
As well, the entire deal must be ratified by all 28 member states of the EU, including 10 regional parliaments, and Canada. Achieving that will be difficult, and could take years. The debate in Wallonia has reawakened opposition across Europe, particularly in Germany and France, where an election next year is expected to focus heavily on CETA.
The fact is that people are increasingly recognizing the need for fair trade deals that protect their rights, and not just the rights of corporations. Fair trade is needed to provide and maintain good jobs instead of forcing a race to the bottom. This rings true for CETA, and it’s true for the TPP.
Both of these trade deals are remnants of the Harper Government, which was thrown out of power more than a year ago for failing to hear or address the needs of ordinary Canadians.
Unifor is in Ottawa this week to remind MPs of that the government should work for us – the residents of Canada. Our union will continue to urge MPs to be part of the movement for a fair trade future – which begins with voting against the TPP.